Opinion

Commentary

"I love my country, but I hate the government."

Kanak Mani Dixit
Kathmandu, Nepal
April 17, 2006

All over the subcontinent, every day, the most disadvantaged fall through the cracks. They are pummeled by the forces of state, market, or feudalism.

For the middle class, the political parties, or those linked to the state there is recourse although it may not be always available or efficiently delivered. The tragedy of South Asia is that those who are left out are not the exception but the rule.

This abuse can cover an entire spectrum of activities, from displacement of tribals from the forest reserves which have been their traditional homes, to trans-boundary missiles that land in the middle of shanties of NWFP, to street-side youngsters devoured by the security machinery of an autocratic state bent on repression.

Article Continues

Advertiser Links

Links open in new window.

Credit Card Search - Search and compare credit card offers

CreditLoan: Finance Advice, Car Loans & Bad Credit Debt Loans

RAM Memory for Computers, Laptops, and Printers. Wholesale!

Travel to Russia: Tickets, Hotels, Tours

Medical Supply

Laptop Batteries Camcorder Batteries

Taken in by Kathmandu's royal regime with two dozen other protestors last week for willfully (and with prior announcement) breaking the curfew order, this writer had opportunity to see how a 'militarizing' autocratic state machinery can ride rough-shod over some of the weakest members of society. It was an opportunity to take a look at the underbelly of the monster that government can be. What we have seen during our incarceration is something that the privileged with contacts in high places or money to buy oneself safe passage rarely care to see or understand.

There are three types of inmates in this makeshift detention center at the Duwakot armed police barracks outside Kathmandu. The relatively well-known human rights activists have little fear of violence once they are taken in. Then there are political activists both senior and junior, who receive some protection through party affiliations and linkages. But here in Duwakot there is an entire category of true innocents.

Most of these young adults, some of them mere boys, are migrants who have left their families in faraway hills and plains to work in menial jobs. They represent the rural poor of all ethnicities and castes, but they are united in their lack of influence anywhere in the state structure. This lack of agency is only matched by their absolute poverty. The trauma that these boys of Duwakot have faced and are facing exists at several levels. First, it is the chase on the streets, the attacks by batons and staffs, the abuse, and the bundling into the back of trucks.

Once in the holding center, where the toilet facilities are non-existent, they are transported from one place of detention to another and provided with no information whatsoever. No food is provided for more than a day, and when it arrives, it is of the lowest grade imaginable. There is fear that authorities in need of proving Maoist 'infiltration' of the democratic movement can with the flick of a pen declare you an insurgent and do away with your life and prospects.

Who will tell the family, who will inform the employer, who is the lawyer or activist to speak for you? Who is to defend you, and to charge the regime with wrongful imprisonment, and seek a writ of habeas corpus, and demand release and reparation?

Dambar Nepali, 14, is from Udayapur in the hills of the east. He worked as a construction labourer and was taken in and beaten while coming home from work. Ramesh Basnet, 23, from Dhading, was returning from the printing press where he worked. Ram Kumar Tamang drove a microbus, license plate No 4266, and was crossing the road during a curfew when he was detained. Biraj Sharma, 18, was loitering outside a roadside shop in an area outside curfew limits. "The policemen were like demons," he recalls, "they kicked my head as if it was a football."

Four kids were resting inside a bus at a bus stop where they worked as cleaners when they were dragged out. They are: Dhruba Timilsina, 17, of Hetuada; Buddha Lama, 16, of Sindhupalchok; Ramesh Thapa Magar,17; and Ram Lama, 20, of Chapagaon. They have all been moved elsewhere.

Individuals who are in the lowest class bracket in detention get the toilet that is furthest, the rice that is the worst. It will be important for the ICRC to determine their fate and whereabouts.

Some policemen can be fine, sensitive individuals. But they take orders from an insensitive state run by a ruler who has sought again and again to prove his contempt for the people of Nepal. When autocracy and militarization is combined with contempt, those without recourse suffer unseen and unheard. This is one more reason for a quick return to democracy, pluralism and peace.

Ramesh Basnet told me the day before yesterday, before he was taken away: "This turns out to be the kind of country I was born into. I love my country, but I hate the government. I have not picked up a stone, I have not burnt a tire in protest, why am I here, and where will they take me?"




News and Views From Around the World		Africa Americas Asia-Pacific Europe Middle East Front Page