In Their Eyes: Assisting the Quake-Affected Children of Pakistan and Azad Kashmir

View slide show. (Photo Courtesy of Kashmir Family Aid)

Indians killed Danish Khawaja's father.

The 12-year-old Pakistani boy with big brown eyes lost his dad to militants from India who fought for the controversial plot of land called Kashmir.

Like many Kashmiris, Danish's father was a jihadist in the India-Pakistan conflict. And like many children in the region, Danish could easily join a jihadist group to strike back at those who killed his father.

Instead, he chooses to become a doctor.

"I want to help people," Danish said between classes on a muggy May morning in Muzaffarabad, the capital city of Azad Jammu Kashmir.

Danish is just one of hundreds of students supported by Kashmir Family Aid, a 501(c)(3) nonprofit based in Bend, Ore. Founded in 2005 by Sam Carpenter and directed by Christopher Stollar, K.F.A. assists children in Pakistan's North-West Frontier Province and in Azad Kashmir, where the Oct. 8, 2005, earthquake killed at least 73,000, left 3 million homeless and destroyed more than 1,000 hospitals and 8,000 of the region's 11,000 primary and secondary schools, according to CNN and Newsday reports.

K.F.A.'s primary goal is to counter poverty and terrorism while promoting women's rights by providing secular education to quake-affected children. No politics. No religion.

Carpenter has been to Pakistan six times now, most recently in late May. He has developed an international perspective on three of the world's most important and controversial issues the American media has often missed when covering Pakistan: (1) education versus terrorism, (2) women's rights, and (3) East-West relations.

That perspective started developing at 8:50 a.m. on Oct. 8, 2005.

The Quake

On that fall morning a 7.6-magnitude earthquake shook the mountains, crumbled buildings, and crushed thousands of people in and around Muzaffarabad, the capital of Azad Kashmir. In Islamabad, Pakistan, just a few weeks after the quake, Carpenter wrote about life on the ground for schoolchildren:

"The quake was violent beyond words, and the children were in school when it came. Generated by the quake, there was a fiendish, from-Hell roar, and their little bodies were knocked flat to the floor to be pummeled over and over as they struggled to get up.

"Each surviving child endured the horror of the quake, and the trauma is evidenced by a vacant stare. Many of them refuse to go to school, afraid the quake will return, associating the terrifying event with school itself. About 20,000 children died. Looking in their eyes, one cannot mistake what has happened here.

"I examine the life I lead back in the states.

"I have been here a week and will spend two more weeks in the quake zone before returning to my home in mid-December. In my upscale Oregon resort community, Christmas will happen with all the trappings. I am expected to return to life in a beautiful home—a life interspersed with Yoga classes and lattes, along with comfortable chatter in my clean and spacious office that is decorated precisely.

"As I sit here, haunted by the tent-camp children's eyes, I reflect now upon the general absurdity of my too-soft Western existence.

"Too much, my life has been wrapped up in things that do not matter."

A New Perspective

After that trip, Carpenter began seriously pursuing recurring donations from corporate sponsors who would join him in his cause of countering this poverty. He and Stollar visited the region in May 2008—two and a half years after the quake.

Despite how much time had passed, they could see signs that the earthquake's aftermath continued to haunt the region. Tents still dotted the hillsides. Concrete rubble littered the streets. And almost everyone spoke of life either "before" or "after" the quake.

One of Kashmir Family Aid's new plans includes constructing a school for 200 orphans and vulnerable children who currently study in tents because the 2005 earthquake destroyed their former school building—crushing dozens of students.

When Carpenter and Stollar met some of these children, the two could not believe how seriously they took their education. Despite rain in the winter and heat spells in the summer, these young boys and girls continued to study in their tents. For them, graduating means more than a piece of paper. It is a ticket out of the slums.

This school project is in Pattika, 20 kilometers (12.4 miles) north of Muzaffarabad.

The school site is on a beautiful meadow looking down on the Nellum River, which roars by far below, brown and turbulent with ice melt from the Karakoram glaciers close by to the east.

If a sponsor can be found, construction of the school will cost $25,000. Once built, that or another sponsor can support the entire operation for less than $1,000 per month, and have his or her name on the masthead.

Teachers in the Pattika tent school make less than $60 a month and had not been paid for eight months upon our visit.

Kashmir Family Aid covered back wages, paying the teachers in Pakistani rupees. In several other projects, K.F.A. plans to pay teachers, build bathrooms (in one school, there is a single toilet for 400 students), and add classrooms to a primary school. Carpenter has six total projects available for individual or corporate support.

K.F.A. will even take interested donors to Pakistan and Kashmir to meet the children and teachers—and see the schools for themselves. While overseas, donors will get to explore the region's wild rivers, ancient mosques, and the world's tallest mountains in the Karakoram region of northern Pakistan. Azad Kashmir is one of the most mysterious and least-visited regions in the world.

Carpenter's experience in Pakistan illustrates a fresh, international perspective on education versus terrorism, women's rights, and East-West relations.

Education vs. Terrorism

Pakistan is a key battleground to the broader struggle between terrorism and the West.

The State Department has concluded that "Pakistan remains a major source of Islamic extremism and a safe haven for top terrorist leaders."

Al Qaeda uses tribal areas of Pakistan to rebuild its leadership and replace killed or captured fighters, according to an April 2008 report by the State Department.

Pakistan is now one of Al Qaeda's key havens, a place where at least one group connected to the Taliban has created thousands of madrassas, Islamic fundamentalist schools that often teach militant jihad to young children, author David Relin wrote in his New York Times bestseller, Three Cups of Tea.

"The madrassa system targets the impoverished students the public system failed," Relin writes. "By offering free room and board, and building schools in areas where none existed, madrassas provide millions of Pakistan's parents with their only opportunity to educate their children."

A World Bank study estimated that by 2001 at least 20,000 madrassas were teaching a strict Islamic-based curriculum to as many as 2 million Pakistani students. Lahore-based journalist Ahmed Rashid—one of the world's leading authorities on the link between madrassa education and the rise of extremist Islam—estimates that more than 80,000 of these young students became Taliban recruits.

While not every madrassa is a hotbed of extremism, the World Bank concludes that 15 to 20 percent of madrassa students receive military training, along with a curriculum that emphasizes jihad and hatred of the West at the expense of subjects such as math, science, and literature.

After talking to Danish, the boy in Muzaffarabad who lost his father to Indian militants, Stollar could see just how easy it is for a young boy to become a jihadist. They get paid well. They have a brotherhood. And their family gets honored when they die.

"The seemingly endless supply of jihadists is not because America has stirred up negative emotions in the area," Carpenter said. "It's simpler than that. In many madrassas, children are educated from their earliest years to hate the West. Then they are offered paid jobs as jihadists. They have not been educated to do anything else. Our secular schools offer a child a chance to learn math, science, English, and history—it's a ticket to a life of contribution and advancement rather than one of religious warfare. Here is where the war on terror will be won."

Aside from countering terrorism, K.F.A. also seeks to promote women's rights in the region—another topic American media have repeatedly missed.

Women's Rights

Bushra wants to become a policewoman.

Her friend wants to teach. Another longs to be a doctor. All three of these young Pakistani children have something in common—their dreams might become reality because of Kashmir Family Aid.

"What we promote is women empowerment," said Mubarik Ahmad, headmaster of the Nilore Model School that K.F.A. financially supports. "And we believe that's through education."

The semi-rural town of Nilore is situated about 40 kilometers (24.8 miles) east of Islamabad.

Ahmad said over a cup of black tea with buffalo milk that he has trouble finding teachers because there is a lack of educated women. Ninety percent of his students come from illiterate families, and 70 percent of their teachers have illiterate parents. Female literacy in Kashmir villages is just 3 percent, according to the Bozeman Daily Chronicle. More than 70 percent of females in Pakistan cannot read at all.

As a result, K.F.A. focuses on educating girls because they tend to marry young via arranged marriages, receive the least amount of education, remain in the villages, or work in the fields.

While Pakistan has many girls' schools, they still meet resistance from terrorist groups. In 2006 the Taliban shot, bombed, beheaded, and burned people alive for allowing girls to attend school. Just last March, the Times of India reported that militants blew up a girls' high school in northwest Pakistan after warning the students to stop attending secular classes and join the madrassas.

Despite this resistance, the schools keep growing because the vast majority of local residents strongly support the secular education of their children.

Nadia, a teacher at the Nilore school, said she already needs more classroom space and computers. She would even like to set up an e-mail exchange program between her students and children in Oregon's public school system.

One of K.F.A.'s projects that a corporate sponsor can support is to add a secondary school addition to the Nilore school at a rough cost of $15,000.

East-West Relations

Contrary to the image sometimes portrayed by the media, most Pakistanis are not terrorists.

Stollar could not believe how much respect the people have for Americans because of the United States' assistance after the earthquake. Whenever he entered a house, the host family stood up. Whenever they sat down for a meal, the family served Carpenter and Stollar first with spiced chicken, lamb, and buffalo milk black tea.

Even in gas stations they were treated like royalty.

Carpenter described this respect during his 2005 visit that brought him to a tent occupied by Shaukat and Yasmeen Ali and their three children, a Muzaffarabad family K.F.A. continues to support:

"I met Yasmeen today while taking a new route back to my temporary living quarters. She says, 'Hello,' with a smile and immediately invites me into her tent for tea. It's always that, the invitation for tea.

"Hissing, the tiny gas stove does its job, sitting on a plank on the floor up against one of the tent walls. There is no food that I can see: just sugar, salt, spices, and some cold soup in a pot, over to the side. Yasmeen fires up an egg on the other stove burner and, against my gentle protest, begins to boil it for me.

"The family speaks haltingly of finding each other after the quake—of the horror of those first nights, the blackness, and the cold rain.

"Things grow silent as I run out of questions.

"I assume the body language of one ready to depart. But before leaving, I ask Shaukat if he has something he wants me to say to Americans.

"'Tell America I am thankful to your people,' Shaukat said. 'And that I want to go to America with my family.'

"I say that America is great because when it started it was filled by people who were poor and who wanted a better life. And, I tell him, the people who live there now still love their country because it has opportunity.

"America began with people just like you."

For more information, visit You can also contact Christopher Stollar at 541-385-1970 or

Sam Carpenter is president and founder of Kashmir Family Aid, a 501(c)(3) nonprofit based in Oregon that assists children of the Pakistan and Azad Kashmir earthquake of 2005. He has visited the region six times, paying for the trips out of his own pocket and through gracious donations.

Christopher Stollar is director of Kashmir Family Aid. He previously worked as a reporter for The Bulletin newspaper in Oregon. Stollar has a master's degree in journalism from the University of Maryland and a bachelor's degree in liberal arts from Gutenberg College, a Great Books philosophy school in Eugene, Ore.